Sof History

Sof Honors Mat Sgan

July 2025

On Saturday, June 16, Sof celebrated the books produced by longtime member Mat Sgan. An oneg was held in Mat’s honor and his authorial accomplishments celebrated. Here is a list of Mat’s books:

Honey and Poi (2018 with Dr. Alex Golub)
The Origins and Development of Congregation Sof Maʻarav in Honolulu Hawaiʻi – A Sof History Project

Dedicated to the leaders, leyners, mentors and workers who have made congregation Sof Maʻarav so important to the personal, religious, social, cultural and spiritual lives of Jews and non-Jews in Hawaiʻi for over four decades.

Torah and Taro (2020)

Jewish Contributions to Hawaiʻi

To the men, women, individuals and families of Jewish heritage who contributed to making Hawaiʻi a better place and to the Hawaiians and the Aloha spirit that enabled them.

Mat’s statement that encompasses all his good works: Torah and Taro (p.179):

I hope this book will bring the reader closer to understanding how people of Jewish heritage have made a difference in Hawaiʻi. Judaism is a religion of universal values, and it is incumbent upon Jews to carry those values forward for the good of societies in which they live. As our prayer book says, “We have come into being to praise labor and to love.” (Siddur Sim Shalom)

 

New! Shaka and Shalom (original 2022)

More Jewish Contributions to Hawaiʻi

This book continues to trace the beneficial crosscurrents that Jewish people brought to Hawaiʻi from their “arrival beginning in 1850 to the present…in some detail and in historical and cultural perspective Shaka and Shalom describes the many good deeds, advantages, and programs that people of Jewish heritage have brought to Hawaiʻi.”

Hula and Hora (2025)

Jewish Families Who Have Advanced Judaism and Jewish Communal Life in Hawaiʻi, Lʻdor vʻdor – from generation to generation.

A vast array of information on each Hawaiian Island and resources. An appendix includes a full listing of significant events in Hawaiʻi Jewish History. Also, Jewish organizations and businesses serving the Jewish community of Hawaiʻi (including the stores that sell Kosher food and have a Passover section).

 

 

 


Torah and Taro


Praise for Torah and Taro

February 10, 2021

Professor Edwin Yamauchi (B.A. UHM; M.A. and Ph.D. Brandeis University) Professor of Emeritus of History at Miami University of Ohio writes:

“I received and read Torah and Taro: Jewish Contributions to Hawaii. I found it informative and fascinating. Robert Littman (p.140) took my place at UH-Mānoa in 1968 when I was on leave at Rutgers University. Aloha.”

Bennett Hymer, President of Mutual Publishing of Hawaiʻi, writes:

“Torah and Taro is a compelling narrative of how Jews have contributed to Hawaiʻi in all aspects of life: business, culture, and the arts. Set against a background of Hawaiian history, the book serves as a good introduction to Hawaiʻi. Mat shows how contributions were made by the well-known and by the everyday person as they carried out their occupation, business, or profession… The reader comes away amazed at what has been accomplished by a relatively small population.”


Torah and Taro

January 12, 2021

A Book Review by Sid Goldstein

Mat Sgan’s third book, Torah and Taro, is an informative history of the Jewish contributions to the Hawaiian Islands. The book examines the impact that the small Jewish population has had on the history, social development, and culture of Hawaiʻi as it transformed from a monarchy to a US possession to a territory and finally to a state in the United States. Sgan repeatedly points out that the population of Jews in Hawaiʻi has hovered around the 1% mark. Yet the contribution of this 1 percent of the population has outsized the numbers disproportionately. From the time of Kamehameha I, the man who unified the Hawaiian Islands into a single kingdom, Jews have played a significant role in the growth and development of the islands.

Mat has done some in-depth research to prepare for the writing of this book. He quotes multiple sources from other texts about Hawaiʻi as well as biographies, newspaper accounts, personal recollections, films, and other media cataloging the history of the islands. It seems that no stone was left unturned in the hunt for source material for the book. Jewish characters abound throughout the book. One notable character is Hank Greenspan. Greenspan was the publisher of the Las Vegas Sun and a noted gunrunner to the nascent state of Israel. Greenspan, it turns out, got many of his weapons from Hawaiʻi. Sgan goes to great lengths to explain how those transactions happened and how the weapons circuitously made their way from Hawaiʻi to the Middle East. Another notable character is Harry Weinberg. Even today one can’t drive around Oʻahu (or any of the larger islands) and not see multiple buildings dedicated by Harry and Jeanette Weinberg. Yet Sgan shows us the ruthless businessman who made a mark on Hawaiʻi by squeezing out competitors and dominating his trade. Later in life we see the philanthropist whose name appears on all those buildings. Sgan’s balanced portrait of Weinberg is a highlight of this book.

Finally, there is the tribute that Mat pays to so many members of Sof Ma’arav for their contributions to the cultural, economic, and educational life of Hawaiʻi. I will not try to list the members of Sof that Mat names. But let me say that we as a community can be proud of how this membership has so positively affected life in the islands. Mat deserves both an aloha and a shalom for so beautifully pointing this out. Torah and Taro is a nicely written, well researched, and positively crafted book. I highly recommend it for anyone interested in a history of Hawaiʻi and how its Jewish citizens helped to shape it to become the place we so love today.


Torah and Taro Press Release

November 29, 2020

Mathew R. Sgan announces the release of Torah and Taro: Jewish Contributions to Hawaiʻi

New book shows how Jews, Judaism and Israel played an important role in Hawaiian history

Book cover Torah and Taro Image of blue sky with a taro plant and a torahHONOLULU – Did you know that pop idol Bruno Mars from Honolulu had a Jewish Ukrainian grandmother to whom he was very close? In Torah and Taro: Jewish Contributions to Hawaiʻi, author Mathew R. Sgan highlights many important and sometimes unrecognized roles that Jews, Judaism, and Israel have played in every stage of Hawaiian history from its first unified Kingdom under Kamehameha I to its present day. Through Torah and Taro readers will learn about Jews in the Hawaiian Islands and how they related to the Indigenous people as well as to other immigrants. Although they make up less than one percent of the population, people of Jewish heritage have made a significant difference to Hawaiʻi.

Sgan investigates matters which researchers have tangled with for many years and raises new ones. Who was the ‘Jew Cook’ who accompanied Kamehameha I aboard the American ship, Neptune, in a Hawaiian port in 1798? What was the relationship to Communism of labor leader Jack Hall and his Jewish advisors who broke Hawaiʻi away from the Big Five corporate oligarchy? Was Catholic architect Alfred Preis influenced by his Jewish heritage in designing the USS Arizona Memorial at Pearl Harbor?

In many ways this book is a love letter to Hawaiʻi. As a longtime visitor and 20-year Hawaiʻi resident, the author’s keen interest in the involvement and growth of the Jewish community in the islands spurred him to research and write Torah and Taro. He describes many historical issues and events in which Jews played helpful roles by assisting Hawaiʻi’s journey along what it determined was its best political, cultural, and social path.

Torah and Taro: Jewish Contributions to Hawaii By Mathew R. Sgan

Hardcover | 6 x 9in | 224 pages | ISBN 9781664132542   $ 31.99

Softcover | 6 x 9in | 224 pages   | ISBN 9781664132535    $ 17.99

E-Book | 224 pages | ISBN 9781664132528       Available at Xlibris.com  $ 5.99

Hardcover and Softcover books available at Amazon, Barnes & Noble, and Xlibris Publishing.

Signed copies available from the author by request to Dr. Mathew R. Sgan.


Praise for Torah and Taro from Fran Margulies

November 29, 2020

I just received a copy of Torah and Taro and am having fun flipping through it and recognizing names! We moved here sixty-one years ago, and I well remember the people you mention. And you have a nice thesis about the Jewish ethic and drive underlying many accomplishments.

Book cover Torah and Taro Image of blue sky with a taro plant and a torah


Honey and Poi

By Dr. Mathew Sgan


Honey and Poi – Sof Maʻarav History Books

Two books, courtesy of the Sof History Project. Honey and Poi provides a history of Sof Maʻarav from its founding in 1971 until today. The Sof Maʻarav History Project Appendix offers additional information and details gleaned from further research.

To purchase copies:

Book orders for Honey and Poi may be fulfilled at:
Web: Xlibris Online Bookstore
Or by contacting Mathew Sgan
Hard cover book: $29.99, plus shipping & handling.
Soft cover book:   $19.99, plus shipping & handling.
Ebook:                    $ 3.99
Shipping & handling cost determined by shipping method.

To purchase a copy of the Appendix, contact Mathew Sgan.

Appendix:               $15.99, plus shipping and handling.

Updated Commentary

March 30, 2021

A recent article in the Tablet web magazine by Joel Kotkin and Edward Heyman is titled “The New American Judaism.” The authors review all the perils (millennial dropouts, intermarriage, low birth rates, Israel’s development) that threaten American Jewry. Using current surveys of American Jews, they go on to suggest that Chabad’s growth signifies one direction that American Jewry is taking. But for American Jews for whom Chabad is not the answer, Kotkin and Heyman present Kehilat Hadar (KH). KH is a 2001 enterprise of Rabbi Eli Kaunfer It is described as a prayer community with a traditional liturgy. It includes a Torah reading, commitment to full gender egalitarianism, services that don’t drag, and congregational engagement through music. The services are led by volunteers and KH has no paid clergy, KH values participation over membership and thrives on ‘network resilience.’ Sound familiar? C’est nous! One of the stimuli for Honey and Poi was to describe Congregation Sof Ma’arav as a kehillah that has blazed such a path successfully. Now some 50 years old and 20 years before KH, the foresight of Sof’s founders is manifest. Mazel Tov to the pioneers of Sof Ma’arav. Sof knew the answer even before surveys, Covid -19, and Zoom made the ongoing discussion about what Is good for American Jewry and how to keep it viable a front burner discussion.


Excerpts from the Preface to the Appendix of the Sof History Project

Sof Ma'arav Appendix

During the course of doing the research for the narrative (Honey and Poi) describing the origins and development of Congregation Sof Ma’arav, I was fortunate to be given a treasure chest of documents, photos, brochures, and newsletters. Such materials were of tremendous importance to recreating the history of Sof and telling its story.  Through them and other sources, I was able to reconstruct lists of Bar/Bat Mitzvahs, office holders, shul finances, and events which added to the record.

While I was able to convey encapsulated reviews of such materials in moving the narrative forward, I felt an additional obligation to share them in some original form with all interested parties. They represent what is beyond the bare bones of the story and have a remarkable ability to transport readers back to being a member at the time the item was paramount.

The original incorporation papers and the names of the incorporators are examples of just who the Sof pioneers were and how they went about making sure that Sof had a firm foundation on which to build. Those papers are included as is a presentation of the actual exchanges during the egalitarian debate (role of women during services), which was a watershed moment in Sof history. That debate as recorded, invites readers to join in the discussion and to consider what their position would have been at that time. It also enables a person to bring a current perspective into the picture.

Organizing and displaying the materials was not best done, in my opinion, chronologically. Rather various topics presented themselves as being the most helpful for readers to follow and understand the nature of Sof during its 40 plus years. Certain topic titles (Communications; Community; Education) enabled me to classify items in an understandable way and to present them in the various forms that they assumed during Sof’s development. The narrative provided the story; the Appendix provided additional perspective and the backdrop of the story.


Honey and Poi – The Modern Years: 2000-2016

A New Century Brings Good News


As Sof headed into the turn of the century, good news predominated. The balance sheet, led by dues, donations and cookbook sales, indicated some $39,000 in income. This enabled Sof to purchase some needed service items (kitchen items, books, ritual products), keep up with operational and rent increases, and pay for outside leadership and associated costs for the 5760 High Holidays.

Even the USCJ (United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism) membership fee was paid without fuss! That had been an issue in prior years. A very positive sign of the times.

President Bernice Littman wrote, in her November 1999 message to the congregation, “5760 is proving to be another wonderful year.” She then went on to thank Ken Cohen for acting as cantor; Aileen Grill for her singing; Robert Littman and Bob Goldman for their talks; George Hudes, Sim Granoff, Marlene Booth and Jordan Popper for leading prayers; Robert Littman and Marv Black for organizing things; and Kat Tsuyemura with Francis Maltin, for managing food arrangements. Gregg Kinkley was applauded for his musical talent, prayer leadership and Torah/haftarot readings. Fran Margulies arranged for baby-sitting and Hinda Diamond collected food for the Hawaii Foodbank.

Bernice indicated that Sof’s reputation as the “party shul” was burnished with great Simchat Torah and Shabbat celebrations, along with Naomi Olstein’s anticipation of yet another lively Hanukkah get-together for latke making and candle lighting. Bernice claimed the “highest level” of member participation in Shabbat and holiday services. Ken Aronowitz and Hinda Diamond declared Sof’s Simchat Torah celebration the most spirited evening in the islands!Even the USCJ (United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism) membership fee was paid without fuss! That had been an issue in prior years. A very positive sign of the times.

President Bernice Littman wrote, in her November 1999 message to the congregation, “5760 is proving to be another wonderful year.” She then went on to thank Ken Cohen for acting as cantor; Aileen Grill for her singing; Robert Littman and Bob Goldman for their talks; George Hudes, Sim Granoff, Marlene Booth and Jordan Popper for leading prayers; Robert Littman and Marv Black for organizing things; and Kat Tsuyemura with Francis Maltin, for managing food arrangements. Gregg Kinkley was applauded for his musical talent, prayer leadership and Torah/haftarot readings. Fran Margulies arranged for baby-sitting and Hinda Diamond collected food for the Hawaii Foodbank.

Bernice indicated that Sof’s reputation as the “party shul” was burnished with great Simchat Torah and Shabbat celebrations, along with Naomi Olstein’s anticipation of yet another lively Hanukkah get-together for latke making and candle lighting. Bernice claimed the “highest level” of member participation in Shabbat and holiday services. Ken Aronowitz and Hinda Diamond declared Sof’s Simchat Torah celebration the most spirited evening in the islands!


Honey and Poi – The Middle Years: 1980-1999

Honey and Poi Cover

 

Background: In the beginning, Sof affiliated with the conservative movement of Judaism and was in touch with its headquarters at the Jewish Theological Seminary for ritual, religious, personnel, and organizational matters. The relationship had, however, not been smooth and questions of money payments and service rose often. In an effort to get back on a healthy relationship, Sof leaders initiated the following steps.

Relations between Sof and United Synagogue of America (now United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism) were once again brought up. President Merle Fischlowitz wrote to Rabbi Benjamin Kreitman, executive vice president of USAM, explaining Sof’s financial predicament and asking to be treated differently from other congregations because of its size, high cost of living, and geographical location. He suggested that the only regional service of which Sof had availed itself was Camp Ramah. Kreitman referred Fischlowitz’s letter to Harold Lipchik, chairman of the Economics Committee of the Pacific Southwest Region (PSWR), which handles the subject of Sof’s dues and relationships as a member of that region. Lipchik thanked Fischlowitz for his letter because the PWSR had been trying to establish contact with Sof for two years without success.

President Fischlowitz had proposed paying a sum of 6% of dues collected in 1985-86, a sum of 5% of dues collected in in 1986-87 plus 0.5% for Camp Ramah. Lipchik stated that Sof’s situation had always been recognized and that, on the basis of a new USAM plan officially beginning in 1987-88, payments to USAM would be based on a percentage of actual dues collected. Moreover, Lipchik was willing to begin this program in 1986-87, providing Sof forwarded 6% of its ’85-’86 dues collection, plus $500 to clear up the $2,737 in arrears at that point. Fischlowitz thanked Lipchik for his constructive letter and indicated that he would be back in touch after consulting with the Sof board. The financial arrangement (6% of collected dues plus $500) suggested in the letters between Merle Fishlowitz and Harold Lipchik of the PSWR of USAM was approved.

Update: Currently Sof pays about $1000 annually to USCJ.  We receive a batch of Luachs (calendar of dates, rituals, aliyahs for services), listing on the USCJ website, publication and personnel information, and other support material from time to time.  


Praise for Honey and Poi

Honey and Poi was published about 3 months ago, and the critical reviews of it have started to arrive.  Here are a few samples:

  1. Perhaps the best book about a small conservative shul on an island in the Pacific thus far this year.
  2. Some may think of Leo Tolstoy’s War and Peace and Sholem Asch’s Tales of My People. Others may not think of those books.
  3. Almost Talmudic in its willingness to let everyone who’s anyone speak.
  4. You will not just read Honey and Poi; you will live it!

Shoshana and I are reading Honey and Poi to one another, and we are enjoying it immensely….What a wonderful contribution you have made both to Sof and to the understanding of Jewish life in Hawai’i. Yasher Koach!

– Rabbi Saul Perlmutter

Still, there are Sofers who have not yet joined in the fun of knowing who we are and how we came to be. Amazon, Xlibris, and Mat await your book and Appendix orders! Consider how happy your friends and family will be to receive these books. Joy unbounded! More information, contact Mat Sgan.


Honey and Poi – Author’s Preface

“I read Honey and Poi in one reading. I couldn’t put it down. I especially loved knowing the details of how the schul came into being, who the pioneers were, and the split involving egalitarianism. It is quite an accomplishment and a great service to our community.” – Gayle Goodman

This book has been a labor of love for me from the beginning. Congregation Sof Ma’arav from my perspective deserves all of the accolades which have been associated with it. I enjoyed writing about a group in which I have been an active participant.

For over four decades, Sof has been an educational center, a religious and spiritual guide, a support group, and an uplifting social setting for many who otherwise would have been without such life affirming associations. It has never turned its back on anyone responsive to and in need of the kind of program it had.

My research has included group and individual conversations, document review in the solitude of early morning page turning, and newspaper articles unfurled awkwardly on microfilm at the library. I was looking for information on the setting of Sof’s development, the people who made it happen, and the key factors of its ability to change without losing sight of the cultural vision of its founders.

In order to accommodate such aspiration, I wanted not only to produce this narrative, but also to provide a depository for Sof’s most important written and pictorial history. Hence, there is an accompanying Appendix which I hope readers will peruse. As my efforts increased, I came to see other aspects of this book. I hoped that it would be of interest to other Jewish people in Hawaii and elsewhere who might be responsive to becoming a more active part of their own heritage.

Perhaps, they would say that it was time to investigate what Judaism is really all about and how it will bring deeper meaning to their lives. Perhaps they will say that Sof Ma’arav or another Jewish organization is the kind of religious gathering that they would be pleased to join or initiate in their own community. I realize that is an elaborate hope for such a modest undertaking, but no one should underestimate the creativity of Jewish people.


From the Sof History Project

By Mat Sgan

Newly elected president Peter Freeman (1991–1992) took a page out of Ronald Reagan’s playbook with a “Morning in Sof” optimistic approach. Beginning with a warm letter to fellow congregants, Freeman invited all to participate fully, and included a committee sign-up sheet. His new-day attitude extended to creating a summer/fall bulletin outlining exciting cooperation with Rabbi Leibowitz at AJC and TE president Steve Welid; organizing summer and weekly Shabbat services; publicizing Sof 1991–1992 officers and board members; and acknowledging a memorable Tisha B’Av service at AJC featuring a talk on Lamentations by Rabbi Jerome Epstein, CEO of USAM. Invitations were sent, especially to AJC and TE, but intended for the entire Jewish community of Oahu, to join Sof in celebrating Selichot (movie: Operation Solomon). Simchat Torah High Holiday services for 5752 were led by Jonathan Webber with commentary by “our scholar in residence,” Dr. Cyrus Gordon. Donors were sincerely thanked, and donations to the Torah fund were encouraged. An August 31 Havdalah followed by the Selichot service took place. Selichot was not only scheduled, it was explained. New Sof leyners added excitement and anticipation to Shabbat and festival services in 5752.


Sof History: Merle Fishlowitz

Oct 27, 2019

By Mat Sgan

We called former Sof President Merle Fishlowitz in doing research for our book Honey and Poi: The Origins and Development of Congregation Sof Ma’arav in Honolulu Hawaiʻi. He responded with deep conviction to questions about his relationship to Sof. After leaving Hawaiʻi, Merle felt so strongly about his Sof relationship that he donated the Torah that we use most often for Shabbat and Festival services.

From Honey and Poi

Two-term President Merle Fischlowitz (1986-1988) spoke highly about his Sof experience:

At Sof I learned about Jewish liturgy, prayer structure, and services. … I had never been aware of such matters, and knowing of them contributed to my education. … I learned by doing and by carefully listening to three or four very knowledgeable Sof members.     

When asked about any feeling of disappointment about Sof, former President Fischlowitz remarked:

You have to make sure that there’s not a rotating, but a growing and changing leadership. … When people come in they should know that their contributions will be recognized and that they can become a part of the decision-making process.

Sof members are in luck. Mat has some hard covers ($29.99), soft covers ($19.99), and Appendices ($15.99) of Honey and Poi for you to purchase as gifts (New Year; Chanukah) for yourselves, your children, and grandchildren. They can learn more about the Jewish spirit. That spirit imbued a band of people committed to maintaining Judaism in their lives and the lives of their fellows with the energy and focus to establish Sof Ma’arav out of whole cloth. An amazing story about a lay-led boot strap shul associated with the structure and benefits of a synagogue, the love and support of family, and the learning of a graduate seminar.

Honey and Poi is also available at Amazon.


Frances Maltin’s Contribution to Major League Baseball

Contributed by Mat Sgan, part of the Sof Ma’arav History Project

As Mat Sgan explains:

Jackie Robinson broke the color line in Major League Baseball in 1947. Before that, and to prepare him and the world for that momentous occurrence, he played for the 1946 Triple A Montreal Royals baseball team. They were befriended by the Maltin family in Montreal.

Below is how Frances describes what happened:

When Jackie and his wife, Rachel, moved to Montreal, they did not live with us, but did become companions and lifelong friends. My father, Sam Maltin, who was a sports writer for the Montreal Herald at the time, is noted for writing this famous paragraph in baseball literary history.

“It was probably the only time that a black man ran away from a white mob with love instead of lynching on its mind.”

This was 1946, after Jackie led the Montreal Royals to the ‘little’ (AAA) World Series Championship. The crowd literally chased Jackie down the street in order to embrace him.

The PBS Jackie Robinson Story talked about how well the family fit into the Brooklyn neighborhood and showed a picture of Jackie and Rachel’s son, Jackie Jr. playing with a little white girl. Well, the picture was actually taken in Montreal and that little white girl is my younger sister.

20 Years A Jew: One Convert’s Observations in Seven Installments

By Athena DeRasmo


Installment 7 – “And then there was Israel…”

Haifa Shrine of the Bab

Haifa. I sat in a tiny office in a government building – bleak, institutional, and oppressive. Like most Israeli government buildings, it could have been a set for a cold war film. Across from me sat a clerk – a stern, Russian-Israeli female about 15 minutes past her prime and more than a little bitter; the perfect government employee. In Israel, many government office workers are Russian females – smart, multi-lingual, indifferent, and frankly a little scary!

It was 2002, and I was making Aliyah. The Aliyah office was very quiet. The violence of the Intifada had brought a dramatic cessation of tourism and immigration to Israel. The year 2002 alone brought 47 separate bombings, with no end in sight. The country felt shut down. Ironically, it was also a great time for converts to immigrate. Minister of Interior Eli Yishai, while very right-wing, was also a pragmatic man. His policies opened the door wide to diaspora converts wishing to immigrate. I guess he figured anyone who was crazy enough to make Aliyah during this bloody time, who was he to stop them!

I had not told a soul of my plans to make Aliyah. I did not contact any of the many immigrant aid organizations. In hindsight, perhaps I should have, but Aliyah is a very personal decision. I figured once I had my Israeli citizenship firmly in place, then I would share the news. I knew I was taking steps that would change the rest of my life; first a new faith and culture, now a new county. There was no way to know how it would all play out – but it felt right, even amidst all the balagan.*

The clerk was processing my paperwork. It was going well; my conversion had been in good order. When my Bet Din was being assembled, I was interested in having a female Rabbi. I had approached one, but was told that if I wanted to make Aliyah, a conversion document with a female Rabbi listed could be problematic. So, my Bet Din was all male, with Rabbi Goldfarb at the helm. Subsequently, my paperwork was HaKol Beseder.* There was a routine interview portion. The clerk then looked at me hard, almost cross, and asked, “So why do you want to live here, now, during all this mess? You are from Hawaiʻi. Are you crazy?” I told her, “Well, I fell in love, it just kind of happened.” She rolled her eyes a bit, and nodded knowingly. I stopped her. I said softly, “No, I mean I fell in love with Israel.” And I watched those stern, bitter, Israeli eyes well with tears.

A few weeks later I became an Israeli citizen.

Field and Tree Golan Heights

________________

*Balagan – mess

*HaKol Beseder – ok, all in order


Installment 6 – Conversion and Jewish “Pedigree”

I have it on good authority that once the conversion process is complete, that’s it! The convert is no longer a convert; they are a Jew. No discussion or question – being a convert needs no disclaimer. If only this were true. There will always be someone who thinks a particular convert is not Jewish enough, the right “kind” of Jew – or even Jewish at all!

Many factors can influence the perception of a convert’s pedigree. Intention: Was the conversion for marriage, or was it spiritual, or both? Why a person converts may be more important than how a person converts. Affiliation: Reform, Conservative, Orthodox, or other movement. Affiliation is a huge deal-breaker for some. Expression: Is the convert Shomer Shabbat, attending only the High Holidays, or are they mostly secular? While I was shul shopping in Maryland, congregants would often ask me, “where do you live?” I thought it a strange opening question, until I realized that they were trying to ascertain whether I drove or walked to shul. Then there is the question of Politics: Is the convert right- or left-leaning, are they supporters of Israel, are they ambivalent? Jews are rightfully attached to their political beliefs. But are politics a good yardstick by which to measure a convert?

When weighing the legitimacy of a conversion, what all these factors have in common is the notion that conversion to Judaism is not necessarily a done deal. Rather, it is contingent on varying ideas defining what is a Jew. In 1999, Hungarian Playwright George Tabori said, “Thirty years after Auschwitz the rabbis are still discussing in detail what a Jew is. Everyone knows it, except the Jews. […] I would not be a Jew if the Germans had not reminded me about it […] To be sure, the price for this conversion was too high.”

With the current rise of demonstrative racism and anti-Semitism; with the world-wide Jewish population still struggling to make a comeback from WW2, every Jew must be considered a precious member of the tribe. Degrees of Jewishness and disqualifying conditions erode the most important attribute of Judaism – the persistent belief in family, community, and service.

As someone who grew up in a dysfunctional family, moving from place to place, the idea of a cohesive community was nothing short of miraculous. As a convert, I continue to be ever amazed that Jews aspire to this goal. However; if we are all to participate in Jewish service for the greater good, there can be no exclusivity – all must be welcome – come as you are.


Installment 5 – Modest* Fashion and the Modern Woman

Mt. Carmel at Night.

Dictionary Definition of "Modesty."

I am not a modest woman – never have been. However, when I was going through conversion, I went through changes. Becoming a Jewish woman would be a big responsibility and I needed my outside to be more in keeping with my inside. I decided that a more conservative appearance would be appropriate. My decision to change to a modest appearance would mean a radical shift in my personal style. Having a background in theatre, I understood the power of costuming and using garb to enhance an experience; however, there would be no artifice in this particular costuming. So, the hemlines came down, necklines came up, I gave up sleeveless fashion, and footwear became practical. I wore my hair simply and covered my head for shul. Like keeping kosher, for me, modest fashion was not going to be a sometime thing, but rather an ongoing representation of my observance. These fashion changes would become permanent, and I grew very comfortable with my decision.

Modest fashion was particularly helpful to me during my five years in Israel as a single woman. My modest fashion acted as a deflector shield for many unwanted advances from some Israeli men (both Jewish and Arab) who believe that single women get off the plane in Tel Aviv in order to meet them. My frum appearance allowed me to travel into areas that are typically taboo for a seemingly unaffiliated woman, such as Arab villages & Orthodox neighborhoods. On occasion, I was called out for pretense – for presenting as something I was not. On one such occasion, in Haifa, I hailed a cab on Shabbat. A secular driver pulled over, curiously asked where I was going. I told him, “The Synagogue at the bottom of the hill,” Mt. Carmel. He said, “You look religious, you go to Beit Knesset, then you act religious – you walk,” and drove away. In Israel, where all opposites meet, you play by the rules!

My time in Israel was 2000-2005. When I returned to the US, I continued to dress in modest fashion, knowing full well that modest is as modest does – and as a modern woman, it has to be asked, what is modesty? Considering the current course of the modern woman, once desirable attributes of “modesty” are no longer desirable – Who would desire their daughters to be timid, docile, reticent, or meek? It would seem that modest fashion and actual modesty have little to do with one another. Modest fashion is neither a guarantee of virtue, nor a misrepresentation of piety. However, it can be said that modest fashion in the modern world is a statement of cultural and religious identity, which also has the added benefit of saying, most unmistakably, “Hey, my eyes are up here!” A modest statement? Thankfully, I think not.


Installment 4 – Balancing Secular and Sacred

Every day this convert is faced with balancing sacred observance and a vast secular life, which challenges my observance at every turn. Shabbat is a big help, the precious island in time, as are the holidays. There is also the plethora of Jewish activism, volunteerism, clubs, and committees, and to be sure, the work is never done! Nevertheless, the question of how to manifest Judaism day-to-day remains a challenge.

Personally, keeping kosher style* is a choice that has been very meaningful, and helps to bridge the gap between the secular and the sacred. When I choose to take the time to carefully scrutinize the purchase, preparation, and consumption of my food, I am inviting a very private observation that allows me to be demonstratively Jewish. Even the mundane task of grocery shopping brings me closer to my goal of living a meaningful Jewish life. To say I do not miss bacon would be a lie. I miss a lot of things – my grandmother’s Vina Dosh (vinegar pork roast), Lau Lau on New Year’s Day, good Italian cold cuts, lobster!

Yes, the list goes on and on. Perhaps this is why keeping kosher is more difficult for new Jews. We did not grow up Jewish; we enjoyed years of forbidden fruit; and we know exactly what we are giving up if and when we decide to keep kosher or kosher style. As a foodie, culinary art school graduate, and former food service professional, keeping kosher was more than just a dietary change – it was a profound cultural and professional change.

So aside from the obvious, that keeping kosher is a mitzvah/commandment that is halachically ordained, why on earth do it? Do I think the Holy One actually cares if I have baby back ribs? No, I do not. Do I believe in keeping kosher for kosher’s sake? No, I do not. Let’s face it, keeping kosher is tough; especially here in Hawaiʻi! Americans are notorious when it comes to food: over-fed and under-nourished.

Conversely, Jews have always had a special relationship with food, and keeping kosher bumps that relationship up a notch. The level of connection that keeping kosher style affords me is very comforting, and I am a little less lost for it. So yeah, I miss bacon, I know what I have lost, but I also know how much I have gained! The decision to keep kosher continues to be the right decision these 20 years.

*“Kosher Style” (for me) means no consumption of non-kosher meat and no mixing of meat and dairy, ever. I am very conscious of hechsher and ingredient lists. I do not separate cookware/dishes/cutlery. Living in Hawaiʻi I mostly defer to vegetarianism.


Installment 3 – “What’s an Orphan To Do?”

With High Holidays 5779 behind us, it seems fitting to comment on what the Holidays mean to this convert. I have heard it said, and I paraphrase, “Time keeps the Jewish people.” The Jewish calendar sustains the Jewish people in the diaspora then and now. It can even be said that time is more important than geography. We do not need to know the exact location of Mt. Sinai, but we do need our calendar to remind us when it is time to commemorate what happened there. We do not need the Kotel, but we do need our holidays. Even precious Jerusalem is just a pile of rocks when compared to the sacred moments in time that make our continuation as a people possible and assured.

So, if time keeps us, then it is right that we turn around and keep time. The Jewish community, families, and individuals share this responsibility – as a conversion candidate 20 years ago, this really sealed the deal for me. The single flame that burns in every Jew would burn in me and follow me wherever I would roam. Be it to different congregations, different lands, new destinies, my life as a Jew came with me and could be manifested in time, anywhere, place did not matter — have Torah, will travel! And so, I did.

For years I would have different homes in different lands, and it was during this time that I discovered that even with the calendar and my Jewish flame, I was in a very practical way – an orphan. My own biological family has never held any interest in my conversion or anything Jewish. They do not even know when the holidays are, what they mean, or even what I can and cannot eat. My conversion is ignored by my family, and frankly, it does not bother me. My conversion is my own. However, what does bring me sadness is when I find myself without a place to go on the holidays. More than once I have created a Seder plate for one, or had a tuna sandwich as my Rosh Hashana feast, or settled for French fries instead of latkes – talk about your bitter herbs! To be sure, congregational events help with this loneliness, a lot! Some years I get very lucky with a really nice private invitation. When I was living with Sophia [my non-Jewish daughter] sometimes it was just the two of us, and that was good too. But the fact is, that without a Jewish family or significant Jewish other the Holidays can be a time that reminds a convert that they are ever so slightly outside of the tribe. This is no one’s fault, it just is.

As the years have gone by my Jewish skin becomes more comfortable, the Jewish calendar is now a natural progression for me, and my flame continues to burn.  I will do my part to keep time, and in turn, time will keep this orphan.


Installment #2 “Why Judaism? What made it special (to me)?”

As I mentioned in installment #1, the form and function of Judaism has always been hugely attractive to me. Who can deny the intellectual appeal, the turning of Torah again and again, and the Socratic method of study? Even for those of us who tend to be more spectator than participant, the questions and curiosities are there, and we are obliged to get involved with the process of Judaism. This keeps Judaism alive, vibrant, relevant, and ready to take on the modern condition.

Another attribute of Judaism that is very intriguing is the inherent disinterest in proselytizing and seeking the conversion of non-Jews. Because, as I see it, deeds are more important than faith, and what we do is more important that what we believe, there is no need for non-Jews to “join the club!” Living a good life is enough. Unlike other monotheistic religions that threaten soul damning repercussions for being a non-believer, Judaism is not in the saving business. I believe it has no interest in placing the yoke of Judaism on others. To me this is the ultimate expression of coexistence and tolerance. I could not resist learning more about a club that was not interested in having me as a member (with regards to Groucho Marx).

The test of time is a useful yardstick by which credibility can be measured. Judaism can certainly boast the attribute of longevity and the respect it commands. It is remarkable to me that after everything, which has occurred over thousands of years, Judaism remains strong and enduring. I recall a proselytizing group coming to my door to share “the word.” When I told them, “This is a Jewish home,” they politely smiled, nodded, and left without a word. I like to believe that their reaction came from respect. I think it can be said that Judaism is the closest thing the world has to an “O.G.” religion still operating in modern times. The permanence of Judaism is a powerful and impressive thing indeed!

When I was going through my conversion process one of the members of my Beit Din asked me about the fact that I was not baptized and that I had no affiliation with any other religious group. I explained that I was born in the 60s and my parents did not see the need to impose belief systems on their children. Furthermore, while they believed religious education was an important part of being an educated person, my parents felt that it was up to the individual to find their spiritual affiliation. As a young person, I did look around, study, and observe, but I was always something of a spiritual orphan. It was a struggle, and as a young woman, I often felt lost. It wasn’t until I was a mature woman that I realized I had been wandering long enough and that it was time to find a home. I was told by a Rabbi, “For you, this is not a spiritual conversion, this is a spiritual adoption.” And so, it was.

I cannot finish this installment without mentioning the resolve and humor of the Jewish people. This feature of Judaism is very endearing and attractive to a non-Jew, and as a conversion candidate, I was no exception. What’s not to love! After all the Jews have been through – to succeed, to persevere, and still have humor – who wouldn’t want to belong to such a family! And so, I do.


Installment #1 The decision to convert: Simple, right?

 

In 1998, I attended Rosh Hashanah services at Sof Ma’arav with a friend. The next week, I returned for Yom Kippur services on my own. After that, I started attending weekly Shabbat Services. I remember that I would open my siddur from left to right and it took a while to break the habit. The congregants may have thought, “What is the deal with this little goyish woman?” but they didn’t let on. I was even set up with a completely transliterated siddur in a three-ring binder, which allowed me to participate in services without knowing a single word of Hebrew. Sof Ma’arav was then, and remains to this day, hospitable and kind to anyone who comes to services. I find this remarkable. It does not surprise me that so many conversion candidates have found their way to Sof Ma’arav.

Even though I am local to Hawai’i, Jews and things Jewish were not unfamiliar to me. My father was a Bronx New Yorker (Italian) who spoke Yiddish and had many Jewish friends. However, my knowledge was cultural and secular, so attending services was something brand new. After a couple of months, I informed my non-denominational family that I was seeking conversion to Judaism. I made my announcement over Thanksgiving dinner. My Grandmother exclaimed, “Oh thank G-d, I thought you were going to tell us you were pregnant!” My being divorced, I guess she thought being Jewish beat the hell out of being pregnant!

Rabbi Morris Goldfarb was to spearhead my conversion education in what proved to be a very busy 15 months. I attended Torah study, regular services, experienced all the Jewish holidays, started keeping kosher, and changed my personal style to Hawai’i modest, floral frum. A Bet Din was selected. On January 2, 2000, the Pacific Ocean was my Mikveh, and the Littmans threw me a lovely party.

Simple, right? Well, no. Conversion to Judaism is complicated. There is a reason it is infrequent and special.

Going back to that first Rosh Hashanah service, I was at a time in my life where I recognized something was missing. I came to understand that my spiritual life was lacking form and function. I remembered when asked if religion was necessary to have a spiritual life, the Dalai Lama said, “Religion is not necessary to have a spiritual life, but it can help!” Experiencing the apparent form and function of the High Holiday services was like a switch being flipped – I was very interested, and I wanted to know more!

Well here I am, 20 years later and very secure in the knowledge that, along with having my children, converting to Judaism is the most meaningful thing I have ever done. I am home. In the next six installments I will share some observations from my journey as a convert, a Jew, and a Woman. Welcome to my story and enjoy!


 

Calendar
Archives
  • Bekhorot 52
    Today’s daf marks the end of chapter eight of Tractate Bekhorot and a departure from our previous subject matter. Concerns ... The post Bekhorot 52 appeared first on My Jewish Learning.
  • Bekhorot 51
    As we have learned previously, a firstborn son who meets the qualifications of a bekhor (the first baby to open ... The post Bekhorot 51 appeared first on My Jewish Learning.
  • Bekhorot 50
    In 66 CE, the Roman procurator of Judea, Gessius Florus, seized 17 talents of gold from the treasury of the ... The post Bekhorot 50 appeared first on My Jewish Learning.