Sof Book Club – A Year in Review

by Members of the Sof Book Club

The Sof book club completed another year of comprehensive, diverse, and often exciting reading of Jewish stories, authors and history. This year, the Book Club met eight times and read the following books:

    

The Beauty Queen of Jerusalem by Sarit Yishai-Levi

Little Failure: A Memoir by Gary Shteyngart

Yiddish: A Nation of Words by Miriam Weinstein

Pumpkinflowers: A Soldier’s Story of a Forgotten War by Matti Friedman

Moonglow: A Novel by Michael Chabon

Maus I and II by Art Speigelman

A Thread of Grace by Mary Doria Russell

The Last Minyan in Havana by Betty Heisler

 

Book club members commented on their favorite selections of the year.

 

Carolann Biederman

Our Sof Book Group relishes being together to discuss great literature, great stories and learning that enhance our Jewish knowledge and experiences. My favorite, and by that I mean, the most powerful reading experiences for 2018 are Art Spiegelman’s Maus I & II and Michael Chabon’s Moonglow.

The sheer creativity and rich construction of each author’s approach, the weight of the stories, the many comical and poignant passages made these two reads unforgettable and highly recommended. Spiegelman took the trail blazing Pulitzer-Prize winning Graphic Novel approach to the Holocaust and Chabon took the conceit of his dying grandfather’s memoir that is actually a novel (or it isn’t).

Both brought me closer to understanding the costs of war and surviving it; the actual functioning of the Auschwitz concentration camp, as well as the power of honest communication and family dynamics in modern times. Maus sat on our bookshelf for 25 years, as I was afraid the impact would be too much to bear, of its stark narrative of surviving Auschwitz. Don’t wait if you haven’t read it.

Gail Marcus

I particularly liked Yiddish: A Nation of Words. This should be a reference book – something that people can use to look up the meaning of Yiddish words when they hear an expression they haven’t heard, or they’ve forgotten.

Sally Morgan

I enjoyed Pumpkinflowers: A Soldier’s Story. This is the story of a disillusioned Israeli solider who told the truth about his experience in the IDF. The clashes along the border with Lebanon meant unnecessary death. The heartbreak of parents losing their children led a solider to question everything he’d been taught before.

Michelle Schneider

When the librarian directed me to the young adult section for Maus, I thought she was mistaken. When I beheld two books in comic strip format, I was convinced she had erred in her selection.

Reluctantly, I began reading Maus I that evening, and finished both books before the end of the night.  A comic book about the Holocaust may seem incongruous, but I was spellbound by this clever, powerful allegory/memoir/novel.  Maus chronicles the survival of the author’s father during the Holocaust, and their present-day strained relationship. The use of black and white panels heightens the impact of this dark period in history; the comic strip format evokes more vivid and more graphic images than simple words alone. The use of animals to depict different nationalities and ethnicities, such as cats for Nazis and mice for Jews, is innovative and ingenious on many levels.

This book should be required reading for all.

Sid Goldstein

My favorite book of the Year was Moonglow by Michael Chabon. The character of Michael’s grandfather was unforgettable. He was a man on the cusp of greatness and fame, only to miss out because he insisted on trying to fix broken people. Chabon shows us how some things that are broken are not meant to be fixed. This is a fascinating story of one man’s Jewish family and their attempts at survival in America in the years after World War II. It is cultural, historic, sardonic and Yiddish all at once. Simply put, it’s a great read.

 

Mat Sgan

Sof Book Club discussions are always very insightful. In a recent meeting, we reviewed a fairly prosaic book titled The Last Minyan in Havana. In addition to deconstructing and reconstructing the book itself at a high level by all members of the club, outside information was introduced. Sid Goldstein offered that 12 Jews were saved on the ill-fated ship St. Louis through the intervention of Eleanor Roosevelt. Eleanor wrote to her husband, President Franklin Roosevelt, urging him to save the 12 by allowing them into the United States. He complied even though he was under great pressure not to do so. More than 900 other Jews aboard that ship had to return to Germany to face the Holocaust. Sally Morgan shared firsthand stories of her family living in Key West, and her husband, US Navy Captain Joseph Morgan, going on maneuvers in the Caribbean during the Cuban revolution period. I spoke about my recent visit to Cuba including a visit to the world-famous Mafia nightclub, El Tropicana. These are just some examples of the value-added experience that Sof Book Club members receive during their gatherings.

Fran Margulies

A standout in our book club year was Miriam Weinstein’s Yiddish, a Nation of Words. Well-researched, it was lightly and engagingly written.  I was charmed, sent copies as gifts, and I recommend it to Sofers.

  • JCAN’s Jewish Climate Conference
    March 24, 2019 1pm-8pm Temple Reyim in Auburndale, MA Join Rabbi Margalit and Organic Torah Board Member Rabbi Laura Bellows as they co-teach Changing Climate, Changing Ourselves. We will only succeed in shifting our direction and pulling back from the brink of climate disaster by feeling the crisis in our bodies and emotions; and also […]
  • Meditation, Nature and Torah: The Missing Links (a Podcast)
    JOIN US–Rabbi Margalit and Rabbi Marc Margolius live online April 3rd at 12:30 EST, or download the podcast later. The aim of spiritual practices such as meditation is that they will help us not only to feel present (or perhaps Presence) while we are meditating, but will help us to maintain that sense throughout our […]